Yesterday, the German Bundestag’s Petitions Committee deliberated on the petition against the proposed Animal Experimentation Act, which was signed by more than 84,000 people. The Bundestag petition, initiated by a coalition of ten organizations*, garnered more than two and a half times the 30,000 signatures required for a public hearing. During the hearing, the coalition reiterated its core demand: The federal government must not remove the regulations on animal testing from the Animal Welfare Act and consolidate them into a separate law. This would threaten to weaken the already inadequate protection of millions of animals in German laboratories.
Dr. Christoph Maisack, a retired judge and first chair of the German Legal Society for Animal Protection Law, spoke on behalf of the coalition as the lead petitioner before the Petitions Committee. Dr. Tamara Zietek, Director of Science at Physicians Against Animal Testing, supported him as an expert on international developments in animal-free science. “Our demand is clear. Please refrain from enacting a standalone animal experimentation law and leave the regulations on animal experimentation where they have been for more than 50 years and where they belong: in the uniform federal Animal Welfare Act,” Maisack emphasized in his opening statement.
The regulations on animal experimentation, which have been enshrined in the Animal Welfare Act since 1972, form a coherent protection system together with the general principles of animal welfare law. A standalone law could disrupt this coherence and result in animals in laboratories being less well protected than other animals. In particular, the alliance opposes any lowering of the requirements for the official review of animal experimentation applications. The assessment of necessity, the availability of alternative methods that do not involve animal testing, and the risk-benefit ratio is central to the protection of animals.
During the hearing, despite repeated inquiries to the federal government, it remained unclear why a standalone animal experimentation law is necessary, even though - according to the Federal Ministry of Agriculture - problems with approval procedures and uniform enforcement could be resolved through a revision of the General Administrative Regulation (AVV)—without lowering animal welfare standards. Dr. Christoph Maisack warned against weakening regulatory reviews and the potential consequences under European law. Referring to the European Commission’s criticism of regulatory project evaluations - which had already been deemed inadequate in the past - he asked: “Do you really want to knowingly run into a new infringement proceeding?”
Even when it comes to the protection of so-called “surplus animals” - those bred for animal testing but ultimately not used and subsequently killed - the coherence of existing animal welfare regulations must be maintained. The Federal Ministry of Research pointed to approximately 240 million euros that have been invested since 1980 in methods to avoid animal testing - amounting to just 5.3 million annually. Nevertheless, the ministry maintained that animal testing remains necessary and will continue to be so. Despite repeated inquiries from members of parliament, no concrete details were provided regarding further steps to expand animal-free methods and the phased phase-out of animal testing in chemical safety assessments.
The coalition emphasizes: Funding individual animal-free methods is not enough as long as policymakers continue to assume that animal testing is indispensable. What is needed is a consistent paradigm shift toward human- or species-relevant science without animal suffering.
The Petitions Committee will now deliberate on the arguments presented and decide how to proceed with the petition. The coalition calls on the federal government to refrain from enacting its own animal testing law, to under no circumstances lower animal welfare standards but rather to improve them, and to consistently advance the transition to modern, animal-free research.
*The coalition includes:
- Doctors Against Animal Testing, Inc.
- Federal Association Against Animal Abuse, Inc.
- Federal Association of People for Animal Rights, Inc.
- German Legal Society for Animal Protection Law, Inc.
- German Animal Welfare Federation, Inc.
- mensch fair tier, Inc.
- People for Animal Rights Baden-Württemberg e.V.
- PETA Germany e.V.
- Political Working Group for Animal Rights in Europe e.V.
- Team Tierschutz gGmbH
Note to editors: The public hearing can be viewed in the German Bundestag’s media library (starting at minute 59).




